can someone answer the question, please, why this planet x is said to be a brown dwarf and not a cluster of comets or one comet.

[nicholas fowler]

Just listening to bob evens on Bill Xam, will post an embedded link later, it is Bobs first interview with Bill and one I have missed.

anyhow, can someone , any of you, please answer, why it is everyone who studies this planet x seems so convinced it is a brown dwarf? I think many say this because this is what seems to be doing the rounds. Jim Maccaney says it is nonsense, and say there are many planet x's and all are comets of some sort. so, what started the idea it is a brown dwarf? where did this idea come from and what reason, scientific reason, not imaginative, what reason is there for saying it is a brown dwarf?

Most people seen to parott this phrase like some religion, but is there any evidence  to back it  Up?

[tracy arnold]

Imo,i think a few scientists and so called elitetist knew the story of nibiru and its connection to the sumerians,tamarains,egyptians,etc.the pictographs of sumeria and ancient tamare,falsely called ancient egypt had ufos,tall beings and a ten planet solar system imbedded in clay tablets as well as on the walls of ancient tamara.the first war in iraq was about more than oil.ancient texts were being unearthed,they probably been finding and knowing things for a while.these texts talk about the return of all the same craft and beings,the anunnaqi now being called planet x a brown,black,red dwarf star.thats what everybody is missing,these ancient cultures communicated and interacted with them.some where along the way the planet craft nibiru becand tales ,myths and so called science.

[Kim B]

Wish I knew.